When a tenancy relationship breaks down, both sides feel stuck. For landlords and building owners, an unresolved dispute means lost rent, maintenance on hold, or premises that can’t be re-let. For tenants, it means living or operating a business under daily stress, facing uncertainty over lease terms, or not being able to leave. Normal communication stops, and breach notices and withheld rent take its place.
Mediation offers a structured way to sort it out. Tenancy mediation brings landlords and tenants together with an independent mediator to negotiate a practical outcome. ResolveWell works with clients across New Zealand to either get the tenancy working again or agree a clean exit.
If yours is a residential tenancy covered by the Residential Tenancies Act, you can if you wish to start with Tenancy Services, which offers mediation and access to the Tenancy Tribunal at low cost. Private mediation is most useful for complex cases , for commercial leases, and for arrangements the Act doesn’t cover, such as flatmates, and where both parties want more time or an earlier date than the public service can offer.
How tenancy mediation compares with a formal legal process
When a lease dispute starts, the usual first move is a formal one: a lawyer’s letter, a breach notice, or a court filing. Sometimes that’s necessary. If rent isn’t being paid and the other party won’t engage, if you need possession or an urgent order, or if a legal deadline is close, get legal advice and use the formal process.
Formal steps can also harden positions. Notices tend to prompt a defensive response, legal costs build, and a hearing can be months away. In the meantime the premises are tied up and neither party has certainty.
Where both parties are willing to negotiate, mediation offers:
- Speed: A mediation can usually be held within days or weeks, which may be before another month’s rent is lost.
- Outcomes a court may not be able to order: A court decides the legal claim in front of it, usually breach and damages. In mediation you can agree arrangements that fit what you both need, such as an early termination, phased move-out dates, a staged repayment plan for arrears, or agreed handover conditions.
- Confidentiality: Court judgments and Tenancy Tribunal orders are generally published. Mediation is confidential.
- Control of your outcome: In court, a third party decides what happens to your lease or property. In mediation, no terms are forced on anyone. You only sign off on an agreement if it makes practical sense for you.
Tenancy and lease disputes we can help you resolve
We mediate commercial lease disputes and private rental disputes, particularly where Tenancy Services or the Tenancy Tribunal doesn’t cover the situation, or the problem is wider than a single claim.
These include:
- Commercial lease disagreements: Arguments over operating expenses (OPEX), rent reviews, maintenance responsibilities, and access disruptions in office, retail, or industrial buildings.
- Reinstatement and make-good obligations: Disagreements at the end of a lease over premises condition, fit-out removal, alterations, and disputed dilapidation costs.
- Early lease termination and surrender: Negotiating clean terms when a business needs to downsize, exit, or assign its lease to another operator, or when a landlord needs vacant possession.
- Rent arrears and payment plans: Addressing unpaid rent constructively, balancing the property owner’s cash flow needs with realistic repayment structures that avoid total default.
- Property damage, repairs, and bond disputes: Unpicking who is responsible for structural vs cosmetic damage, neglected maintenance, or the fair release of bonds and deposits.
- Non-standard and shared living arrangements: Flatmate fallout, head-tenant disagreements, private boarder issues, and shared housing conflicts that fall outside the Residential Tenancies Act.
Repairing the tenancy or ending it cleanly
Most people in a tenancy dispute want one of two things: the relationship repaired so the tenancy can carry on, or a clean break.
Mediation can deliver either:
- Keeping the tenancy alive: If both sides want the lease to continue, mediation focuses on resolving the immediate disagreement and agreeing how you’ll communicate and deal with problems in future.
- Agreeing a clean exit: If the relationship is beyond repair, the priority shifts to negotiated exit terms. We help parties agree on specific handover dates, key returns, final settlement figures, and release of liabilities so both sides can move on.
Working with Mark Sinclair at ResolveWell
A tenancy dispute is about the lease, but it’s also about whether a business can keep trading, someone’s home, cash flow, and how the two parties have been dealing with each other.
ResolveWell is led by Mark Sinclair. Mark has a legal background and is expert at helping parties resolve issues and repair relationships. He helps landlords and tenants look past their stated positions to what each of them needs, which is usually where a practical solution is found.
Mark works with clients across New Zealand, in person or online.
Frequently asked questions about tenancy mediation
What if the other party refuses to communicate or cooperate?
Communication often stops because past discussions turned into arguments or threats of legal action. Many people avoid talking because they fear being pressured into an unfair arrangement. ResolveWell can reach out to the other party independently to explain the mediation process. Once people understand that mediation is voluntary and impartial, they’re often more willing to take part. If they still refuse, mediation can’t go ahead and you may need to use the formal process.
Can we mediate online if someone has already moved away?
Yes. Tenancy disputes often involve parties in different towns, or former tenants who have moved away. Online mediation lets everyone take part from where they are.
Do we need our lawyers or property managers involved?
That’s entirely up to you. Some clients prefer to handle the mediation directly to keep costs low and speak plainly. Others, particularly in commercial leases with significant financial obligations, prefer having their lawyer or property manager present to advise them during the session.
What happens if we don’t reach an agreement?
Mediation is voluntary and without prejudice. If you can’t reach an agreement that you’re happy with, you haven’t given up any legal rights. You remain free to go to court, arbitration or the Tenancy Tribunal.
Ask us about your situation
Contact ResolveWell for a confidential, no-obligation conversation about resolving your tenancy or lease dispute.